The Dead Rabbit occupies the ground floor and first floor of a 19th century building on Water Street in Lower Manhattan, two blocks from the East River and one block from the site of the original Five Points slum that inspired the bar's name. In 2016, it was named the world's best bar. In 2017, it was named the world's best bar again. No bar had ever done that before. The men behind it are Jack McGarry and Sean Muldoon, two bartenders from Belfast who came to New York with a specific vision and the discipline to execute it precisely.
Their story is, at its core, about the difference between a great idea and a great bar. Many people have great ideas. Very few have the operational rigour to build something that sustains excellence at volume, night after night, for over a decade. Dead Rabbit has done that. Its reputation is built not on a single iconic drink or a theatrical concept but on the consistent delivery of one of the most demanding drinking experiences in American bar culture.
From Belfast to Lower Manhattan
McGarry and Muldoon met while working in Belfast's bar scene in the early 2000s. Muldoon had already built a reputation as one of Ireland's most technically precise bartenders. McGarry was younger but possessed the obsessive work ethic and competitive instinct that would define the bar he eventually built. Both men were drawn to the history and technical depth of pre-Prohibition American cocktail culture, a period when American bartending was the envy of the world before the Volstead Act dismantled the industry for 13 years.
When they moved to New York in 2011, they began research for a project that would take 18 months and consume an extraordinary level of financial risk and personal commitment. The concept: a 19th-century Irish immigrant tavern in downtown Manhattan, serving the full spectrum of cocktails from a menu designed around historical recipes, house-made ingredients, and an understanding of drinks culture that extended back to the 1830s.
"We did not want to make a theme bar. We wanted to make a bar where the theme was accuracy. Everything had to be real, or it was worthless."
The Dead Rabbit opened in February 2013 on Water Street. Within three months it had a waiting list most nights. Within a year it held the number one bar position in America on nearly every major list. The cocktail industry took notice.
The Menu as a Document
Dead Rabbit's cocktail menu is unlike almost anything else in the industry. It is a printed booklet, illustrated with Victorian-era imagery, organized by spirit category and historical period. The flip section alone, featuring egg-based cocktails warmed with a hot poker that were popular in 18th-century American taverns, has introduced an entire generation of drinkers to a format that had been virtually extinct for 200 years. The research behind each cocktail menu takes 6 months to complete. Every drink is tested 40 to 60 times before it appears on the list.
This level of investment in menu development was, at the time of Dead Rabbit's opening, genuinely unusual even in a city that had produced Milk and Honey and PDT. The investment has paid off in the most direct way: the menu is taken as seriously by guests as the drinks themselves. Regulars plan visits around new menu launches. The seasonal menus have been collected by cocktail enthusiasts in the same way people collect wine vintage charts or jazz concert programmes.
The Flip and the Forgotten Cocktail
The dead rabbit gang of 19th-century New York, whose name the bar took, were Irish immigrants who fought a series of street battles with nativist gangs in the Five Points neighbourhood in the 1850s. The historical specificity of the reference is characteristic of the entire bar. Nothing at Dead Rabbit is chosen arbitrarily. The name, the decor, the menu structure, the cocktail categories, and the bar programme all follow a coherent historical logic.
The flip cocktail deserves particular mention. Originating in American colonial taverns as a warming drink made from ale, rum, sugar, and a beaten egg, then heated by plunging a red-hot iron poker into the mixture, the flip had been largely forgotten by the 20th century. Dead Rabbit researched the format extensively, developed a safer modern approach, and put 8 flip variations on their first menu. The drinks were unlike anything most guests had encountered. They were viscous, warming, and complex in a way that bears no relation to modern cocktail styles. The flip section became one of the most talked-about elements of Dead Rabbit's programme and has since been adopted, in various forms, by bars from Tokyo to Copenhagen.
Consistency at 600 Covers a Night
The element of Dead Rabbit's operation that the industry finds most impressive is not the research or the historical references. It is the consistency at volume. On a Friday night, the bar serves upward of 600 guests across both floors. Every cocktail produced on the Parlour floor must meet the same standard as the first drink of the evening. The mise en place system, the staff training programme, and the quality control procedures developed by McGarry and his team are as sophisticated as anything in the restaurant industry.
McGarry has spoken about the influence of fine dining hospitality standards on Dead Rabbit's operations. He spent time early in his career studying how Michelin-starred kitchens achieved consistency at volume, and applied those lessons directly to bar management. The result is a bar that can produce 800 cocktails in a night with a coefficient of variation in quality that would satisfy the standards of a scientific experiment. This is not hyperbole. It is what world-class operational management looks like when applied to cocktail production.
If you want to understand where New York's bar scene has been and where it is going, Dead Rabbit is the essential reference point alongside Attaboy. Our guide to the best cocktail bars in New York places both in the broader context of a city that has 22 venues operating at international recognition level. For the hidden-room experience that complements Dead Rabbit's historical rigour, see our list of the best speakeasy bars in New York.
After the Awards: Dead Rabbit Today
McGarry and Muldoon had a public disagreement in 2017 that resulted in Muldoon's departure from the business. McGarry bought out his partner and continued running the bar alone, a transition that tested the institution's resilience. Dead Rabbit survived. The bar's systems, culture, and standards proved strong enough to outlast the founding partnership. The research programme continued. The menu quality remained. The Parlour floor still serves some of the most technically accomplished cocktails in the city.
What the transition revealed was something that the best bars always ultimately depend on: a culture that outlives any individual. At Dead Rabbit, that culture is now 12 years old. The bartenders who learned there have gone on to open venues across New York, Dublin, London, and beyond. The bar's influence on the drinks industry, like Attaboy's influence, runs deeper than its award record. It runs through the people who passed through it and took its standards with them.
Planning Your Visit
Book the Parlour floor table 3 to 4 weeks in advance for weekends. Weekday evenings before 8pm are more accessible. Start with the bartender's recommendation from the current seasonal menu. Order a flip at some point during the evening. The Irish coffee downstairs in the taproom is worth 30 minutes of your time before heading up. The walk along the waterfront after is a natural extension of the experience. Pair the evening with the Manhattan bar hopping guide for a full Financial District to West Village route that places Dead Rabbit in the context of the broader downtown drinking circuit.
We cover bars with real depth of history, craft, and conviction. Tell us about yours.
Submit a Bar
